Peer Review Process
Cybermatrix: Journal of Information Systems, Artificial Intelligence and Technology applies a rigorous peer-review process to ensure the quality, originality, relevance, and scientific integrity of manuscripts published in the journal. All research and review articles submitted to Cybermatrix are evaluated through a double-anonymous peer-review process, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other during the review process.
Each submitted manuscript undergoes the following stages:
1. Initial Submission Check
The editorial team conducts an initial administrative check to ensure that the manuscript complies with the journal's submission requirements, manuscript format, focus and scope, and required metadata. Manuscripts that do not meet the basic submission requirements may be returned to the authors for correction before further evaluation.
2. Editorial Screening
The Editor evaluates the manuscript's relevance to the journal's focus and scope, originality, academic quality, methodological adequacy, and overall suitability for peer review. Manuscripts that are clearly outside the journal's scope or do not meet the minimum scholarly standards may be rejected at this stage without external review.
3. Similarity Screening
Manuscripts may be screened using plagiarism-detection or similarity-checking software before proceeding to external peer review. The results are evaluated by the editorial team to identify inappropriate textual overlap, plagiarism, duplicate publication, or other potential concerns regarding publication integrity.
4. Reviewer Assignment
Manuscripts that pass the editorial screening are assigned to at least two reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area. Reviewers are selected based on their academic expertise, independence, and suitability to evaluate the manuscript.
5. Double-Anonymous Peer Review
Reviewers evaluate the manuscript independently. The review process considers the originality and significance of the research, clarity of the research problem, appropriateness of the methodology, validity of the analysis and results, quality of the discussion, relevance of the references, clarity of presentation, and contribution to the field.
Reviewers may recommend one of the following decisions:
- Accept Submission
- Revisions Required
- Resubmit for Review
- Decline Submission
6. Author Revision
When revisions are requested, authors are expected to revise the manuscript carefully and provide a clear response to the reviewers' comments. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers or evaluated by the Editor, depending on the nature and extent of the revisions.
7. Editorial Decision
The final decision on a manuscript is made by the Editor based on the reviewers' evaluations, the authors' responses and revisions, and the manuscript's compliance with the journal's editorial and ethical standards. Reviewer recommendations inform the editorial decision but do not independently determine the final outcome.
8. Editorial and Production Process
Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, proofreading, layout, and production before publication. Authors may be asked to review and approve the final proof before the article is published.
The editorial team is committed to maintaining the confidentiality, impartiality, and integrity of the peer-review process. Editors and reviewers are expected to disclose any potential conflicts of interest and must not use unpublished information obtained through the review process for personal or professional advantage.
