Publication Ethics
Cybermatrix: Journal of Information Systems, Artificial Intelligence and Technology is committed to maintaining high standards of integrity, transparency, accountability, and ethical conduct in scholarly publishing. This publication ethics policy applies to all parties involved in the publication process, including authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher.
The journal's editorial practices are guided by generally accepted principles of publication ethics and good editorial practice, including guidance developed by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
1. Responsibilities of Editors
Editors are responsible for ensuring the integrity and quality of the editorial and peer-review process. Editorial decisions must be based on the scholarly merit, originality, relevance, methodological quality, and suitability of manuscripts to the journal's focus and scope.
Editors shall:
- evaluate manuscripts fairly without discrimination based on authors' personal or institutional backgrounds;
- maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and information related to the review process;
- ensure that manuscripts are evaluated through an appropriate and impartial peer-review process;
- avoid using unpublished materials disclosed in submitted manuscripts for personal research or advantage;
- disclose and appropriately manage potential conflicts of interest;
- take reasonable action when concerns regarding research or publication integrity are raised; and
- make publication decisions independently based on academic and editorial considerations.
Editors should recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where a conflict of interest could compromise, or reasonably appear to compromise, editorial impartiality.
2. Responsibilities of Reviewers
Peer reviewers contribute to editorial decision-making and assist authors in improving the quality of their manuscripts. Reviews should be conducted objectively, constructively, confidentially, and within the agreed time frame.
Reviewers shall:
- evaluate manuscripts based on scholarly and methodological considerations;
- provide clear, constructive, and evidence-based comments;
- maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and review materials;
- not use unpublished information obtained through peer review for personal or professional advantage;
- identify relevant published work that may have been overlooked by the authors where appropriate;
- inform the editor of suspected plagiarism, substantial overlap, duplicate publication, or other potential ethical concerns; and
- disclose any conflict of interest that may affect their ability to provide an impartial review.
A reviewer who feels insufficiently qualified to evaluate a manuscript or is unable to complete the review within an appropriate period should inform the editor.
3. Responsibilities of Authors
Authors are responsible for the originality, accuracy, integrity, and ethical conduct of the research reported in their manuscripts.
Authors shall:
- submit original work that has not been previously published and is not simultaneously under consideration by another journal;
- accurately present the research methods, data, results, and conclusions;
- appropriately acknowledge and cite the work of others;
- avoid plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, inappropriate data manipulation, and duplicate or redundant publication;
- ensure that all individuals listed as authors have made appropriate scholarly contributions to the work;
- acknowledge individuals who contributed to the research but do not meet the criteria for authorship, where appropriate;
- disclose relevant sources of funding and potential conflicts of interest;
- obtain necessary permissions for copyrighted materials used in the manuscript;
- comply with applicable ethical requirements for research involving human participants, personal data, animals, or other areas requiring ethical oversight; and
- promptly inform the journal if a significant error or ethical problem is discovered in a submitted or published article.
4. Authorship and Contributorship
Authorship should be limited to individuals who have made substantial scholarly contributions to the conception or design of the study; acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data; development of software or other substantive research components where applicable; or preparation and critical revision of the manuscript.
All listed authors should approve the submitted and final versions of the manuscript and agree to be accountable for their contributions.
Requests to add, remove, or rearrange authors after submission must be accompanied by an appropriate explanation and agreement from the relevant authors and are subject to editorial approval.
5. Plagiarism and Originality
Cybermatrix requires manuscripts to be original. Plagiarism in any form, including unattributed copying, inappropriate paraphrasing, substantial textual overlap, or the presentation of another person's ideas, data, images, or work as one's own, is unacceptable.
Submitted manuscripts may be examined using similarity-detection software. A similarity report is used as an editorial screening tool and is not interpreted solely on the basis of a numerical similarity percentage. Editors evaluate the nature, source, extent, and context of any detected overlap before making an editorial decision.
Manuscripts involving plagiarism or other unacceptable forms of duplication may be rejected. Concerns identified after publication may result in appropriate corrective action.
6. Data Integrity, Fabrication, and Falsification
Authors must not fabricate, falsify, selectively manipulate, or intentionally misrepresent research data, results, images, code, or other research materials.
Where appropriate, authors may be requested to provide supporting data, documentation, code, or other materials necessary to clarify questions concerning the integrity or reproducibility of the research.
7. Duplicate and Redundant Publication
Authors must not submit substantially the same manuscript simultaneously to more than one journal. Publication of substantially overlapping work without appropriate disclosure and justification is considered unacceptable.
If a manuscript builds upon previously disseminated work, the relationship between the works should be transparently disclosed and the previous work appropriately cited.
8. Conflicts of Interest
Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose relationships or circumstances that could reasonably influence, or appear to influence, their judgment.
Potential conflicts may include financial, professional, institutional, academic, or personal relationships. The existence of a conflict does not necessarily prevent participation in the publication process, but it must be disclosed and appropriately managed.
9. Research Involving Human Participants and Personal Data
Research involving human participants, identifiable personal information, or other sensitive data must comply with applicable ethical and legal requirements.
Where ethical approval or informed consent is required, authors should state the relevant information in the manuscript and be prepared to provide supporting documentation upon editorial request. Personal and confidential information must be appropriately protected.
10. Use of Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Technologies
Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors because they cannot assume responsibility or accountability for scholarly work.
Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, citations, and content of their manuscripts when AI-assisted technologies are used. Substantive use of generative AI or other AI-assisted tools in the research or manuscript preparation process should be transparently disclosed when relevant.
AI-generated content must not be used to fabricate data, references, results, images, or other scholarly evidence.
Editors and reviewers must protect the confidentiality of unpublished manuscripts and should not upload confidential manuscript content to external AI systems where doing so could compromise confidentiality, intellectual property, or data protection.
11. Corrections, Retractions, and Post-Publication Concerns
Cybermatrix will consider appropriate post-publication action when significant errors, ethical concerns, or research integrity issues are identified.
Depending on the nature and severity of the issue, actions may include the publication of a correction, clarification, expression of concern, retraction, or other appropriate editorial notice. Such actions should preserve the scholarly record and clearly communicate the reason for the correction or change.
12. Allegations of Research and Publication Misconduct
Allegations of misconduct will be considered carefully and fairly. The editorial team may request clarification, supporting documentation, raw data, or other relevant evidence from the parties involved.
Where appropriate, the journal may communicate with authors, reviewers, institutions, or other relevant parties in investigating a concern. Decisions will be based on the available evidence and applicable principles of publication ethics.
13. Publisher Responsibilities
CV. Triwira Sinergi Nusantara, as the publisher of Cybermatrix, supports the editorial independence of the journal and the implementation of ethical scholarly publishing practices.
The publisher works with the editorial team to maintain the integrity of the scholarly record, address ethical concerns, and ensure that commercial or organizational considerations do not improperly influence editorial decisions.
